Making Audio for Youtube - How to Combat Stable Volume
Hi all, it looks like this feed is mainly links to videos, but I just thought I’d share some advice as text, which should be hopefully helpful to know.
One of the repeat clients I have is a Sound Recordist who has a popular channel on Youtube, where he posts black screen sleeping rain videos. I use his library of rain beds and thunder sounds to help him churn out weekly videos, and also help him understand audio processing and analyse the videos’ performance.
Now, for those of you who don’t know, you should definitely be aware of Youtube’s awful ‘Stable Volume’ feature. It is essentially a heavy compressor to smash everything up to -16 [edit: actually -14] LUFS (Loudness Units), and it is ENABLED BY DEFAULT. Go check it in the settings icon in the player.
(You can check how much the video is being pushed by right clicking on the video, clicking “Stats for Nerds” and looking at ‘DRC’ - the negative figure is how far below [-14] the video was to begin with, i.e how much gain/compression has been applied).
For the most part, consumers will not notice this feature as a lot of videos are loud, have music and aren’t particularly dynamic - which is what this feature is designed for. But it is painfully obvious on a quiet rain soundscape uploaded at -23 LUFS that has the occasional thunder peak. This relaxing atmosphere suddenly becomes a seasick journey of relentless pumping from the compressor whenever anything louder happens.
Gone are the days you can post videos at the intended volume, with no compression. It is going to get compressed, massively, by default, so it is essential to process your audio correctly before uploading.
Using a loudness meter such as the free YouLean Loudness Meter, you can check that the levels are right on your video before uploading. I recommend getting above -17 or -18 LUFS (integrated) for Youtube. If you are struggling not to introduce peaks at this level (as it is pretty loud), then use gentle compression and a limiter.
Of course, in an ideal world the standard would be quieter and everyone would just turn their volume up and we wouldn’t have to limit anything, but it is FAR better to control how your audio is limited than to surrender to the mercy of Stable Volume.
Since working with this client, all our videos use Sonible’s smart:limit, at -1.1 TP and mixing to make sure the thunder doesn’t noticeably pump the audio, at around -16-18. When viewed with Stable Volume, it hardly has any room to push anymore, so it doesn’t decimate the audio. On one of his solo videos, he had comments complaining that the rain was dipping with the thunder - so I asked what happened and it turns out he decided not to use the limiter on that video. So this is clearly essential to get better representation of your intended audio on today’s Youtube!
TL;DR control the loudness level before it goes on Youtube so it has less headroom to compress it to hell.